Probably late for this thread but someone searching might benefit. I also have a 2012 Fatboy Lo. Over 50,000 miles now, I've ridden the stocks, a few sets of Commander II's and last a couple of sets of Dunlop American Elite's. For me, there's no comparison. The Elite's are a far better match for this bike. Much more secure on the twisties and considerably better wear than the others. A harder rubber than the II's so you feel the road a minimal amount more, but well worth it for how confidently they corner. I can't speak to how they do in foul weather.