I just bought an '09 Nightster a week ago, and put forward controls on it. I have about 400 miles clocked, and the seat is killing me. I was hoping it would break in. I get about 30-35 miles and my ass goes numb. Also, I am about 6'. The bike is comfotable with the forward controls, but I think a seat that sits back about an inch or two would suit me better. Has anyone got any experience with aftermarket or genuine HD seats? I prefer to keep the solo seat look. Thanks.